BIOTECHNOLOGY AND BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES RESEARCH COUNCIL RESEARCH GRANT APPLICATION REFEREE'S REPORT FORM REFERENCE NO: COMMITTEE: APPLICANT: INSTITUTION: PROJECT TITLE: ----------------------------------------------------------------------- REFEREE: ASSESSOR: INSTITUTION: ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SECTION 1: KNOWLEDGE OF APPLICANT/SCIENTIFIC AREA See guidance notes. Include comments NOT to be communicated to the applicant. Include: 1. Familiarity with the scientific area 2. Knowledge of the applicant(s) 3. Whether the applicant contacted you in connection with this application. ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SIGNED: NAME (BLOCK CAPITALS): DATE: (Page 2 contents to be communicated to applicant(s). REFERENCE NO: ASSESSOR: PROJECT TITLE: ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SECTION 2: OVERALL ASSESSMENT Comment on scientific excellence and overall competitiveness of the proposal, taking into account the factors identified in the guidance notes. 1. Scientific excellence 2. Strategic relevance 3. Posperity and quality of life 4. Timeliness and promise 5. Cost effectiveness ----------------------------------------------------------------------- SECTION 3: SPECIFIC COMMENTS (Identify any specific points you wish the applicant to address before the application is considered by the Committee.)